Papa's Tomato Pies was founded in 1912, is the second oldest (arguably the first) pizza restaurant in the entire nation. The tomato pies are absolute perfection and they rank in our top 3 as our unofficial choice of the best tomato pies in the Trenton area. They are well known for their high quality, old school friendly atmosphere, and extremely reasonable prices.
Most dishes are between $10 and $12 and you will sure to bring home leftovers.